The Good Sisters (2009)

Breanne Good and her younger sister Kindra have lived in a modest Maryland home hiding a secret life. They are both practionioners of witchcraft. When a mysterious man moves into their house next door, the siblings become suspicious of their new neighbor who also leads a secret life. Unsure if he is obsessed with knowing about them, or if he has an agenda, the sisters will have to draw up all their powers to confront the man.